Consulting-style slides: how to build a clear argument

Consulting-style slides are useful when a presentation has to explain analysis and back a recommendation. They depend on an organized argument, evidence readers can check, and consistent formatting. The same habits work for a strategy proposal, an internal review, or a client presentation. Start with what you recommend and why.

You don't need to copy a consulting firm's look. Build a deck that suits your organization and its audience.

Write a recommendation you can support

State your proposed action in plain language. “Run a limited service pilot before expanding nationally” gives readers something specific to assess.

Then explain why it follows from your analysis. Maybe demand is uncertain, operational requirements need testing, or a pilot could answer an open question. If your analysis isn't finished, recommend what you can support now. You can recommend further investigation, as long as you say what it needs to establish.

Don't present a confident answer just because the template has a box for one.

Organize reasons into a useful sequence

List the main reasons behind your recommendation and the evidence each one needs. For the pilot above, that might be customer demand, delivery feasibility, and financial exposure.

Check for overlap, because a cost estimate that turns up under several headings makes the reasoning harder to follow. Check for gaps as well. A proposal that covers demand and cost may still need to show you can actually deliver.

Use a structure proportionate to your decision. If a few well-supported reasons are enough, skip the elaborate framework.

Give headings a specific meaning

Where your evidence supports it, write headings that state a finding or recommendation. “Pilot economics” could become “A limited pilot would cap the initial investment.” The slide then has to show the investment amount, its assumptions, and anything excluded.

Keep uncertainty in the heading when it's there. “Interview findings suggest demand among existing customers” says something quite different from “Demand is established.” Then read the headings in order, like an outline. A colleague should be able to find the recommendation and see how the supporting sections connect.

For reference material that doesn't make a single point, a descriptive heading is fine.

Build a slide around the evidence it needs

Use the smallest set of information that supports the heading. A comparison might need a table, a demand pattern a chart, and a delivery model a process diagram.

Give enough context for someone to check your interpretation. Charts need units and a period, estimates need assumptions, and interview findings need to say whose views they represent. If it isn't obvious why the evidence matters, add a short line explaining it.

Keep caveats next to the claims they affect, and move long calculations into an appendix with a clear reference.

Use a consistent slide structure

A good analytical slide usually has:

  • A specific heading

  • A chart, table, diagram, or structured explanation

  • Necessary labels and annotations

  • A source and any caveats

Pick stable margins and text styles and keep similar charts consistent throughout. Within those rules, layouts can vary. A full-width table and a chart with a short explanation need different arrangements.

How dense a slide is should depend on its content. A reading deck may need more explanation than a live presentation, but both need readable text and clear grouping.

Check the basis of each comparison

If two options cover different periods or scopes, explain the difference. If a cost estimate leaves out implementation, say so right next to it.

For qualitative ratings, define the criteria before you score anything, and keep your evidence so someone else can follow the assessment. Watch out for false precision. A score of 7.4 implies a measurement process you may not have, and a clearly explained qualitative judgment is often more honest.

For forecasts, keep assumptions separate from observed results, and consider a range where a single figure would hide real uncertainty.

Use an appendix people can navigate

Organize supporting material by question or section and give each slide a descriptive title. Include definitions, calculation detail, research methods, and supporting comparisons, and point to specific backup slides from the main deck.

The appendix should support the argument without being needed to make sense of every headline, so keep essential caveats in the main deck. If the presentation will be circulated, make sure readers can get at the sources, within any confidentiality limits.

Review the argument before the formatting

Ask a colleague to identify your recommendation and its strongest evidence, and what would make them disagree. Their answers will show you unsupported claims, missing alternatives, or unclear assumptions.

Then check alignment, chart formatting, references, and page numbers, and review the final reading version separately.

Sources

1. Penn State University: Teaching Scientific Presentations
https://www.writing.engr.psu.edu/teaching_presentations.html

2. MIT Communication Lab: Structuring a Slide Presentation
https://mitcommlab.mit.edu/nse/commkit/structuring-a-slide-presentation/

3. Carnegie Mellon University: Executive Summaries
https://www.cmu.edu/student-success/other-resources/handouts/comm-supp-pdfs/executive-summaries.pdf

4. Carnegie Mellon University: PowerPoint Oral Presentation Slide Design
https://www.cmu.edu/student-success/other-resources/resource-descriptions/powerpoint-design.html

5. Office for National Statistics: Choosing a chart type
https://service-manual.ons.gov.uk/data-visualisation/chart-types/choosing-a-chart-type

‍ ‍

Want your own slides to look professional?

Book a call or email us.

Next
Next

9 top presentations from training and teaching materials